German parliament approves most sweeping intelligence reforms since World War II

Bundestag German parliamentTHE GERMAN PARLIAMENT HAS approved the broadest and most wide-reaching reforms of the country’s intelligence services since the end of World War II, enabling its spy agencies to move beyond intelligence gathering and engage in offensive operations. Germany’s Minister of the Interior, Alexander Dobrindt, a leading advocate of the bill, called it the “reform of the century,” arguing the new powers are essential to counter growing hybrid threats.

On 13 November, the Bundestag, Germany’s federal parliament, approved the Law on the Reform of Intelligence Services by 308 votes to 190, with 71 abstentions. The governing Christian Democrats and Social Democrats backed the legislation, while the far right Alterative for Germany (AfD) and the left-wing Die Linke opposed it. Approval by Germany’s upper house, the Bundesrat, is required to complete the legislative process, with the main provisions due to take effect on 31 December.

The law (.pdf) allows Germany’s domestic intelligence service, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV), to engage in covert action against threats to property and information technology systems, providing a specific threat is identified. Such action includes deleting stolen data from an attacker’s server, disabling explosives or weapons, and diverting or blocking data flows during cyberattacks. Under strict conditions, and always with prior authorization, BfV agents may also covertly enter homes, and in narrowly limited exceptional cases it may use 16-and 17-year-olds as informants.

The law also grants Germany’s foreign intelligence service, the Federal Intelligence Service (BND), powers to carry out covert action abroad, such as disabling severs used by state-backed hackers and disrupting disinformation networks. Neither agency is permitted to make arrests or conduct open searches. An Independent Control Council will review the most intrusive measures in advance, taking over duties from the G10 Commission and the Data-Protection Commissioner, which currently oversee Germany’s intelligence community.

The reform comes amid growing concerns in Germany over Russian sabotage, cyberattacks, and other forms of hybrid warfare. In his comments, Minister Dobrindt described Germany as a “theater of operations for terrorism, extremism, and foreign powers.” One incident cited repeatedly in the parliamentary debate was the August 2026 discovery of an explosive-laden drone nearby cargo owned by the Ukrainian-owned firm Antonov Airlines at Leipzig-Halle airport. Berlin formally accused Russia of involvement in the incident, prompting strong denials from Moscow. Read more of this post

German parliament may sue government to access British spy files

Angela Merkel and David CameronA German parliamentary committee investigating spying operations may take the German government to court in order to force it to give up secret documents on Berlin’s intelligence cooperation with Britain. The Committee of Inquiry into Intelligence Operations was set up in 2014, after files leaked by American defector Edward Snowden revealed 1 that the United States had been spying on the telephone communications of German Chancellor Angela Merkel. But the scope of the committee expanded earlier this year, when it emerged that, while being spied upon by the US and Britain, Germany also collaborated 2 with American and British intelligence agencies in order to spy on France and other European countries.

Last week, the German Office of the Federal Prosecutor concluded 3 its criminal investigation into alleged espionage operations by the US National Security Agency against Chancellor Merkel. German officials said they had to drop the probe because of the unwillingness of US government officials to share information on the subject. But the parliamentary committee continues the inquiry on the related subject of Germany’s intelligence cooperation with the Britain and the US. The committee’s chairman, Dr. Patrick Sensburg, said on Thursday that his team of investigators would consider “going to court” in order to force the German government to release all relevant documents. Speaking 4 to the British newspaper The Daily Telegraph, Dr. Sensburg said that the parliamentary inquiry had a right to investigate intelligence cooperation between Berlin and London.

However, as intelNews reported 5 in February, the British government is said to have warned Germany that all intelligence cooperation between the two countries will be terminated should classified information about British intelligence operations be shared with an inquiry. Dr. Sensburg was asked by The Telegraph whether reports of the British warnings were true, but he responded that he was unable to comment on the matter.

► Author: Joseph Fitsanakis | Date: 19 June 2015 | Permalink: https://intelnews.org/2015/06/18/01-1718/


  1. J. FITSANAKIS “US surveillance or Merkel’s phone prompts angry German reaction” intelNews [24oct2013] ↩
  2. J. FITSANAKIS “Airbus to sue Germany for helping US spy on its operations” intelNews [01may2015] ↩
  3. T. SCHLEIFER “Germany drops probe into U.S. spying on Merkel” cnn [13jun2015] ↩
  4. J. HUGGLER “German spy inquiry could demand access to British secrets” The Daily Telegraph [18jun2015] ↩
  5. J. FITSANAKIS “Britain threatens to stop intelligence cooperation with Germany” intelNews [13feb2015] ↩

News you may have missed #679

Salem al-HassiBy IAN ALLEN | intelNews.org |
►►New spy chief in Libya. Libya’s ruling National Transitional Council yesterday appointed a lifelong opponent of slain Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi as the country’s new intelligence chief. Salem al-Hassi, who was involved in a bid to assassinate Gaddafi in 1984, was appointed as the intelligence chief at a meeting of the council.
►►Anonymous hackers release German classified information. Hackers from the group Anonymous said last week they had accessed classified German files and posted them online, revealing details of the country’s military operations in Afghanistan. The military documents were collected for an inquiry, now finished, into a September 2009 airstrike by US jets under German orders that killed more than 140 Taliban fighters and Afghan civilians. Anonymous said it obtained the data from a server at the Bundestag  (German parliament).
►►Did Chinese espionage lead to F-35 delays? Did Chinese cyber spying cause the United States’ F-35 Joint Strike Fighter’s cost spikes and production delays? This is the question being asked by US Pentagon budget officials, according to industry magazine Aviation Week. Chinese spies apparently hacked into secure conference calls and listened to meetings discussing the classified technologies aboard the jets. In particular, China may have stolen info about the F-35’s secure communications and antenna systems, leading to costly software rewrites and other redesigns to compromised parts of the plane.